Are You an Overprotective Dad?

Let me tell you a personal story involving my daughter…

It’s the closing week of the Democratic party’s primary. Hillary and Barrack are going down to the wire, so Bill Clinton is in town campaigning for his wife. We decided to head down to the park where he’ll be speaking, just so we could say we saw President Clinton.

The park was only a dozen blocks from our house, so we decided to ride our bikes. I attached the baby trailer to my bike, we all put on our helmets, and off we went.

Once we got to the park, it seemed that the whole town had shown up. President Clinton was running late, so we parked our bikes next to the park’s jungle gym and let Olivia loose to play with all the other kids. Shan headed off to say hi to some friends of ours, and I stayed by the jungle gym to keep an eye on Olivia.

Eventually another parent I knew walked by, so we started talking for a bit. After a few minutes I turned around to make sure Olivia was okay, but wait… where is she?

Where’s Olivia?

Every square inch of that jungle gym was literally packed full of kids, so it was taking a little time to scan all the faces looking for her.

The relief I felt having her in my arms was so strong that I physically felt it.

Nothing. Where is she?

Okay, don’t panic. She’s here. Just keep looking.

Still nothing.

I turned away from the jungle gym and scanned the surrounding crowd. I couldn’t see her anywhere. Admittedly, I was starting to panic a little at this point.

Turning back to the jungle gym,  I hoped beyond hope that somehow I missed her the first two times I looked, but she still wasn’t there.

Instinctively I rushed out into the crowd, frantically looking for her. About one minute later, I finally spotted her. She was all the way across the park near the stage, happily wandering around saying “hi” to all of the people.

Thankfully, she was perfectly safe.

I ran up to her, picked her up, and the relief I felt having her in my arms was so strong that I physically felt it.

Have you ever had a moment like this with your kids?

It’s terrible, but chances are your child was perfectly safe and sound, just like Olivia was. So where’s the boundary between being a good dad, versus being overprotective?

Last April, Lenore Skenazy let her 9 year old son ride the bus and subway home by himself—from downtown Manhattan! I understand there’s a big difference between my 2 year old daughter and her 9 year old son, but still…

My brother-in-law told me that kids are safer today than they’ve been in years, and if you look up the statistics, he’s absolutely right.

A couple years ago I was in a Super Target with my brother-in-law and nephew, who was about 6 years old. My brother-in-law let him run around the store by himself, which made me nervous enough to say something. My brother-in-law told me that kids are safer today than they’ve been in years, and if you look up the statistics, he’s absolutely right (and my nephew was fine).

It’s sad, but we’ve almost been brainwashed to freak out worrying that our kids will be abducted and harmed. We’re told that if we don’t child proof every inch of the house and watch them every moment of every day, something bad will happen.

I’m determined not to be an overprotective dad, realizing that the bad things that happen to kids are rare, and even happen to the children of overprotective parents.

Yet when Olivia takes off through the crowd, or runs out onto a busy street and almost gets hit by a pickup truck—unfortunately a true story—my fatherly instinct is to get overprotective.

What’s your story?

How would you describe yourself? Are you overprotective? Have you ever had a close call or scary incident with your children? Please share your thoughts and experiences in the comments section below.

No tags for this post.
  • http://dadtrek.com Jon

    @Jeff Rose
    I agree there’s a certain level of being “protective” that’s appropriate. But I don’t want to be that dad who tries to shield my children from everything… to the point of suffocating them, which some parents do.

    There’s a balance, and it’s interesting trying to figure that out. Being a dad sure does involve a lot of on the job training, doesn’t it? :)

  • http://www.goodfinancialcents.com Jeff Rose

    Nothing wrong in being overprotective. For some reason, I could see myself reacting the same way. A similar incident happened in the men’s section of Macy’s. My 15 month old was out of my site for about a minute and I nearly had a panic attack. Turns out he was hiding underneath one of the clothing racks.

    When I was younger, after my parents split, my mom sent me to my dad on a plane from CA to IL. I was only 5 years old. I don’t remember it. But what my dad told me was that I ran off the plane for the flight attendant could find me. They almost had a heart attack. Are kids sweet?

    Jeff Rose’s last blog post..Interview With Joe Plemon

  • http://www.adadsnotes.com/ Stephen Connolly

    I had an incident in the local library when the twins were about two. My son Henry had a fascination with the elevator (the children’s section was in the basement). He’d gotten off the elevator on the main floor and wandered into the office behind the circulation desk, which was next to the exit. He got lost in the stacks and began calling out to me. I prefer taking my kids to parks where I have a clear view of them and they can’t duck around a corner. We all dread that heart in the mouth feeling when you can’t spot them.

    Check out this story about a dad in a community which neighbors our who was prosecuted for child endangerment when his two year-old was found wandering near a main street:
    http://www.southtownstar.com/news/1297155,112508lostgirl.article

    Stephen Connolly’s last blog post..You Know You’re Old When …

  • http://dadtrek.com Jon

    @Stephen Connolly -
    Sigh, I just don’t get some dads. That guy was more concerned about his dog? Seriously?

  • http://www.adadsnotes.com/ Stephen Connolly

    He said that he was “studying” – sleeping more like.

    Stephen Connolly’s last blog post..You Know You’re Old When …

  • marco

    My son's a little guy (as am I) so my antennae start to buzz the moment I think he might be bullied. my dad was a bit of goon in terms of teaching me how to cope – being Asian, the default method in the 70's was martial arts. i was taught to attack the side of the neck. can you imagine? – a 5 or 6 year knee-jerk reacting by attacking another 5 or 6 year with strikes to the side of the neck, shins and kidneys.sadly, i was considered a problem child all the way up to high school.

    when i had my own son, i was determined never to teach him 'san sau', a form of short attack fighting that's effective against bigger opponents. but the first time i saw my son get verbally abused by another 3.5 year old, my first inclination was to tell to tell my little boy to strike the other kid's shin to bend him over for moment followed by a quick hook to the neck.

    fortunately i played the entire scenario in my head and bit my tongue – hard.

    i've never worried more than after i had my son and at that moment, i realized that there is no length i wouldn't go to to ensure my son safe – both in mind and body

    i simply cannot stop worrying about him because i see myself in him.

  • marco

    My son's a little guy (as am I) so my antennae start to buzz the moment I think he might be bullied. my dad was a bit of goon in terms of teaching me how to cope – being Asian, the default method in the 70's was martial arts. i was taught to attack the side of the neck. can you imagine? – a 5 or 6 year knee-jerk reacting by attacking another 5 or 6 year with strikes to the side of the neck, shins and kidneys.sadly, i was considered a problem child all the way up to high school.

    when i had my own son, i was determined never to teach him 'san sau', a form of short attack fighting that's effective against bigger opponents. but the first time i saw my son get verbally abused by another 3.5 year old, my first inclination was to tell to tell my little boy to strike the other kid's shin to bend him over for moment followed by a quick hook to the neck.

    fortunately i played the entire scenario in my head and bit my tongue – hard.

    i've never worried more than after i had my son and at that moment, i realized that there is no length i wouldn't go to to ensure my son safe – both in mind and body

    i simply cannot stop worrying about him because i see myself in him.